The classification question every operator faces
When you hire your first cleaner, you'll face an immediate decision: are they an employee (W-2) or an independent contractor (1099)? Most new operators default to 1099 because it feels simpler and cheaper. That assumption has cost operators tens of thousands in back taxes and penalties.
HMRC and the IRS both have specific tests for worker classification. The key factor isn't what you call the arrangement — it's the reality of how the working relationship functions.
Warning: Misclassifying employees as contractors can result in back payment of employer NI contributions, penalties, and interest. The risk increases significantly once you have multiple workers or regular recurring engagements.
The control test: what actually determines classification
The core question is: who controls how, when, and where the work is done? If you tell a cleaner which clients to visit, what time to arrive, what products to use, and how to clean — that's an employment relationship regardless of what your contract says.
Genuine contractors set their own hours, use their own equipment, take on multiple clients, and can send a substitute. If none of those apply to your cleaners, they are employees in the eyes of the law.
What each option actually costs
Employee costs include employer NI (13.8% above the threshold), holiday pay (5.6 weeks statutory minimum), pension contributions (3% minimum), and potentially sick pay. These add roughly 20–28% to your direct labour cost.
Contractor arrangements have no employer NI but carry misclassification risk if the relationship doesn't genuinely meet the contractor test. Use the P83 Contractor Agreement generator to document the arrangement properly if using contractors.
Ready to launch in your market?
P83 gets you live in 21 days — territory analysis, systems, leads and staff all handled.
Work With Us →